I suspect that this debate will rage for years—the debate over the “correct” viewing order for the fourteen episodes that comprise the first animated season of The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya. It will be one of the Great Otaku Questions, up there with “What in blazes actually happens at the end of Evangelion?” and “What’s it like to go on a date?”
Sorry, cheap shot.
I watched the fansubs—a little late, I know; I should not have let Warren give me copies, but my greedy little nerd heart demanded more. I’m buying the special edition DVDs immediately, so all’s well that ends well, yes? But I digress. The episodes. The fansubs have them in broadcast order; the standard DVD release will be in chronological order.
Hunter, bless his heart, contends that the broadcast order was a cheap gimmick, and that there’s no reason to watch it out of chronological order.
I disagree, but for reasons I myself don’t fully understand. I do think that the Big Reveal needs to be at the end. By that time most viewers have more-or-less figured out what’s going on, but the solution to the Big Problem is more of a surprise, and I think it has more impact if it comes right at the end of the series.
I realize that I am speaking in vague generalities that could hit at anything from “lunch” to “apocalypse,” like some kind of nerd Nostradamus; for this I apologize, but it really is worth staying free of spoilers.
Anyway, Haruhi is really quite special, and no matter how loudly its praises have been sung, I can’t bring myself to call it “overrated.” It simply isn’t. My jaded literature student heart has been moved by this show, moved by the quality of its writing and characterization as much as the postmodern audacity it has to be both itself and a parody of itself.
It was with such admiration, and a new enthusiasm for the animated medium as a whole, that I queued up Genshiken.
I’m going to take a break from fannish raving now, perhaps discussing Genshiken another day, but let me leave with this: Between Planetes, Gunbuster 2, Haruhi, and Genshiken, I’ve seen more paradigm-shiftingly good anime in the last six months than I’d seen in the six years before that.
God help me, I think I’m being sucked back in.